Skip to content
Carmel Rickard writes…
  • Home
  • About
  • Articles
  • Subscribe
  • Contact
Site Search

In their own words …

  • 20 September 201924 September 2019
  • by Carmel Rickard

Sluggish counsel taken to task

AG v Registrar of the High Court & Ors High Court, Lesotho

Judge Charles Hungwe

Judge Charles Hungwe of Zimbabwe has agreed to hear some high-profile and politically-charged criminal cases in Lesotho. In a recent application preliminary to the start of the actual trial, he took the occasion to point out certain shortcomings in the behaviour of local counsel and to indicate that he would not let this continue under his watch.

As has become the norm with legal practitioners in this court, the timelines were neglected.

I must take this opportunity to state that the time has come for this court to take a firm grip of the proceedings and get these matters back on the rails. A party to litigation is bound by the conduct of his or her legal practitioner. A party whose legal practitioner is (a) sluggard bears the consequences of such conduct. Counsels are advised to heed this advice. The proceedings will follow agreed timelines henceforth.

 

Avoiding perception of judicial incompetence & waste: a proper means test

AG v Registrar of the High Court & Ors High Court, Lesotho

Judge Charles Hungwe

In this part of his decision, Judge Hungwe questioned the way the registrar of the high court in Maseru had granted pro deo legal help to the many accused, without going through the proper process. It could lead to allegations that judges were wasteful of public money if the process was not conducted properly, he warned.

Usually, in other jurisdictions in the region, a means test inquiry is antecedent to the grant of an application for pro deo legal assistance. An applicant for pro deo … is required to complete a form outlining his or her monthly income and expenditure. An assessment of eligibility is then made. The expenses are funded by public funds. Transparency in how these funds are disbursed is of fundamental importance if a perception of profligacy or incompetence by the judiciary or its officers is to be avoided.

Read judgment

*Newsletter, Judicial Institute for African (Jifa), 20 September 2019

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
Another kind of crime
Stunning decision by the Supreme Court of the UK

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to Carmel Rickard writes... via email. Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.


Tags

CCMA (3) chief justice (3) Commercial court (2) constitution (5) constitutional and human rights division (3) constitutional court (4) constitutional rights (5) corruption (3) Court of Appeal (4) Covid-19 (6) COVID-19 regulations (3) damages (3) death penalty (5) dismissal (2) Employment law (6) eSwatini (2) Gauteng (3) Ghana (3) high court (23) Judge John Mativo (2) judicial independence (3) judicial review (3) Judicial Service Commission (3) jurisdiction (3) Kenya (15) Law Society of Kenya (3) Lesotho (5) magistrate (5) Malawi (8) Namibia (13) Rwanda (2) SA (4) SA Constitutional Court (2) SADC Tribunal (2) SA Labour Court (2) security forces (4) sentencing (4) South Africa (4) Supreme Court (11) Tanzania (7) torture (4) Uganda (9) UK (2) Zambia (6) Zimbabwe (14)

Recent Posts

  • Preserve your independence, court urges Namibia’s election commission 19 July 2020
  • African Court tells Tanzania: your constitution violates basic rights 16 July 2020
  • Government’s ‘contempt’ raised in challenge to Tanzania’s bail-ban laws 22 May 2020
  • Malawi appeal court judges set new election standards 22 May 2020
  • What orders did the court issue in the case brought by the family of Collins Khosa? 16 May 2020

Archive

Site by Neogek
Theme by Colorlib Powered by WordPress
 Logo Header Menu
  • Home
  • About
  • Articles
  • Subscribe
  • Contact

Subscribe to Carmel Rickard writes... via email. Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.